Direct T.V. vs. Cable

The new home I purchased doesn't have any sort of cable or dish connected to it. I am

debating whether to have Comcast install a line to the house or opt for the "DirectTV"


sort of dish. Any comments? Recommendations? Negative feedback is also appreciated.

Does the DirectTV work reliably in storms and inclement weather?



Direct T.V. vs. Cable

I just switched from cable, which has a monopoly in our Southern California area, to

DISH Satellite. I have a better selection of channels, am paying less money and so far

have been pleased. With regard to the weather, we had no problem with the heavy rains

and winds we experienced this year. Regarding snow, that I cannot address. (05/23/2005)

By Angelina

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

I have been pleased with DISH network. In our area, you can even get local channels. The

cost is much less than cable, and the channel selection is awesome.

We had DirectTV a few years ago, and it was OK, but DISH is a lot better. DirectTV

went out a lot, due to weather, etc., but we really haven't had that much trouble with


Dish. (05/23/2005)

By profile=thr479248">teddygirl

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

I am not able to get cable, but I had a large dish and tore it down because of the

expense and went to DISH. Where I live in Arkansas I get severe weather and it will go

out because of the wind or lighting. I just turn to the local channels. DISH is great,

the movies are cheaper and no hassle on your billing. (05/24/2005)

By profile=thr939848">mrmoose71943

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

We had Comcast and the cable was on and off all the time. We switched to Direct TV and

we have never experienced interruption. (2 years and counting!) (05/24/2005)

By Tedebear

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

I love DISH mostly because of the channel guides. Don't forget to program in your

favorite channels. Take the time to follow the directions at the menu site, it's worth

it otherwise you have to page through way too many channels you never ever watch. Cable


has this, but only on their expensive packages. (05/24/2005)

By Jeneene

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

I've had DirectTV for 2 years and never once has there been a problem. I find it rather

expensive. Just the basic package, plus HBO is 76.96 a month. (05/24/2005)

By Annie

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

We switched from cable to Dish Network because cable kept going up in price.
It does lose it's satellite connection when the weather acts up, rain, storms, etc., but

for the difference in money we accept that. (05/24/2005)

By Beverly in TN

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

We have DirectTVv and we love it. We just weathered 4 hurricanes last summer in Florida.

Our area was directly hit by 3 of them. Our DirectTV never missed a beat. We were

without power for almost 3 weeks after one of the storms and we used our generator to

hook up our DirectTV. My mother had cable TV and lost reception during three of the

storms. It will always be DirectTV for me. (05/24/2005)

By profile=thr520185">klr2080

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

I had DirectTV, for about eight years. It was wonderful, in the beginning. The price

soon went up, and then I started having a totally blank screens. They said it was from

the sun. Then I started having blank screens in the winter. They said it was the snow.

No compensation on my bill, for all the days lost to blank or still picture screens.

So, I finally got fed up and said cancel my account. I will be trying Dish Network, next.

As far as DirectTV, I would never sign on with them again! (05/25/2005)

By systyl

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

I have DirectTV for 5 years and like it. Whenever I called customer support for the few

problems, they were very helpful. The only time I lost the reception was in a very hard

rainstorm and this was for only an hour or so.

Christy (05/30/2005)

By creaky

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

If you live in an area with a lot of cities nearby, such as New Jersey, you should get

DirectTV. If you live in an area without much people, such as Alaska, you should get

Comcast. The reason: DirectTV is cheaper and the better choice overall, but they don't

send as powerful signals from their satellites to rural areas. (08/29/2005)

By Smwbigboss

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

Wait for Verizon TV over an all fiber network. Cheap and reliable. (07/13/2006)

By Mendez212

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

I tried Comcast's Triple Play, and what a headache it was. My voice was always sounding

like a robot. I was constantly resetting the reset button on the modem. My internet

would either quit totally or freeze. If I turned on the HDTV and computer at the same

time, the picture would not work correctly neither would the computer. Comcast should

stick to cable only! (08/27/2007)

By Unsatisfied with Cable

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

Satellite offers superior picture quality over cable. Sure, a heavy rain storm can

degrade the picture, but this happens rarely and it's only temporary. The bigger issue

for reliability is with cable service. I had cable for several years before switching to

DirectTV. Cable was always the first utility to go out and the last to come back on

when a wind storm hit and caused our lights to flicker. If you don't believe me just ask

anyone who is using VOIP with cable Internet service. Try not having phone service for

several days after a wind storm. The infrastructure for cable is extremely fragile and

don't be fooled there's plenty of places where the cable in the ground and in your home

will lose signal strength and degrade picture quality. I had both cable and Direct TV

connected into my TV at one time before switching to DirectTV. The picture quality was

clearly better with DirectTV.

As for the people complaining about their installation not being done right and the dish

moving in the wind, you can tighten the screws yourself. (09/05/2007)

By Patrick

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

DirectTV in my opinion is a company that has horrible customer service, questionable

business practices and are in to turning customers over to collections instead of

solving a problem. I was a customer for 10 years and had recently received a new box

from DirectTV tech support to solve an ongoing problem with not being able to view two

different channels at the same time. The new box did not solve the problem. I sent the

box back to them and canceled the Direct service now they are charging me a large early

cancellation fee after 10 years of having their service. I would recommend getting

anything, but DirectTV. (06/26/2008)

By Rob

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

I just changed to DirectTV and let me tell you there's a big difference. DISH is 100

percent better then DirectTV. (07/02/2008)

By Rosa

Direct T.V. vs. Cable

Warning! I tired DirectTV as a new customer and had nothing but trouble, the signal

goes out constantly, trouble shooting by phone is ineffective, unreasonable service

response time (over 1 week to get service tech appointment date). I tried to cancel

after 5 weeks of continual frustration and got stuck with a $482 cancellation fee!

DirectTV provides poor service and unethical business practices.


By profile=thr400906">landesrbl


Add your voice! Click below to comment. ThriftyFun is powered by your wisdom!

In This Article
Direct T.V. vs. Cable
February 2, 2011
Coaxial Cable TV
Getting Rid of Cable TV
Photo of a TV remote control.
Saving Money on Your Cable Bill
Closeup of HDMI Cable
Saving Money on HDMI Cables
Canceling Cable and Phone Service
Advice on Canceling Cable and Phone Service
Halloween Ideas!
Ask a Question
Share a Post
You are viewing the desktop version of this page: View Mobile Site
© 1997-2016 by Cumuli, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Published by . Page generated on October 24, 2016 at 7:20:05 AM on in 3 seconds. Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of ThriftyFun's Disclaimer and Privacy Policy. If you have any problems or suggestions feel free to Contact Us.
Loading Something Awesome!