How can you make brown-colored frosting that is not chocolate? My nephew wants a football birthday cake, but he does not eat chocolate. I have not had luck with coloring the frosting brown. I would rather not have to buy a container of brown food coloring. Any help would be appreciated.
Red and green food color can be used to make brown. (02/28/2005)
Red and green make kind of a brownish-greyish kind of yuk. I was hoping someone had some other ideas. (02/28/2005)
What about just making the cake another color, such as off white (buttercream) with the laces made of shoestring licorice? (02/28/2005)
By Katie A.
What about dark brown sugar added to white frosting? (02/28/2005)
Brown color - mix the following:
How about a bit of coffee or tea to white frosting? I'm not sure how much or if it would taste too much like either of the above. Or maybe cola? (02/28/2005)
Wilton has a good selection of food colourings- their brown is very concentrated. You can get them at any Michael's store or cake decorating stores. (03/01/2005)
You could top the frosting with crushed graham crackers or a similar colored cookie. (11/08/2007)
The 6 red, 4 green, and 6 yellow suggestion does not work. It is a yucky grey, anything but brown. (12/19/2007)
I tried this recipe and it worked:
We added more drops of each color because we made quite a bit of frosting. (09/13/2008)
By Ann F
I've read that orange and a small amount of black will make brown. (Red and yellow), and if you happen to have a black tube of frosting, it may work. (10/09/2008)
Mix yellow and blue to make green, then add green and red to get brown. (11/16/2008)
Adding cocoa powder helps. Warning: 6 red, 6 yellow, and 4 blue gives you a blueish grey color. (12/22/2008)
I use this and it dyes the icing a light brown:
Just go to Walmart and buy a jar of Wilton brown gel paste food coloring its about $1.25 and it will make it much easier and they last forever. So you would never have to buy more and since its gel paste its concentrated so you only have to use a little. (03/01/2009)
Add your voice! Click below to comment. ThriftyFun is powered by your wisdom!