If you are not successful getting the grease stain off; couldn't you just oil the entire tray and make it match? They make special oil for wood cutting boards and bowls; though mineral oil would probably also do a good job. (Do not use a vegetable oil--they can go rancid over time.)
Login using the form on the top of the page to post feedback (if you are a registered user). If you have not yet registered, click here to do so. It's FREE!.