All-American Style Potato Salad

contest winner icon
This is an old family recipe and might take a little longer to prepare than some of the quicker ones today, but you sure will enjoy the difference. It's easy enough, so just have fun making and sharing it with those you love most.


  • 8-10 eggs (hardboiled, peeled, and chopped)
  • 5 lbs. new red potatoes
  • 1 Tbsp. salt for boiling potatoes
  • 1/2 cup sweet pickle juice
  • 1/2 cup yellow Ballpark mustard
  • 1/2 cup Hellmann's mayonnaise
  • 1 cup sour cream
  • 1/2 tsp. celery seed, or to taste
  • 1 tsp. salt
  • 1/2 tsp. black pepper
  • 1/2 cup red onion, finely chopped
  • 1/2 cup celery, finely chopped
  • 1/2 cup sweet pickle cubes
  • 1/2 cup fresh parsley, finely chopped


You can boil and peel the eggs the day before if you like, but I boil mine at the same time the potatoes are boiling so that the eggs are still slightly warm when I add the dressing. Just as the potatoes do, the eggs absorb so much more flavor when they are warm.

Wash potatoes very well and trim them if necessary. I scrape all the skin off mine with a teaspoon, but you can leave the skin on if you want to, providing the potatoes are really small and the skin isn't going to be tough. I would still trim out the eyes and any spots on the potatoes.


Add potatoes to a large pot and cover with cold water. Add 1 Tbsp. salt, cover them, and bring them to a brisk boil. You need to watch them as they will boil over if you don't.

When they start to boil, lower the temperature, replace the lid on the pot, and simmer until potatoes are tender. Remove from burner and drain the potatoes, saving the cooking water to make yeast breads or to cook another vegetable like green beans or broccoli, peas, or carrots.

Put potatoes back into the cooking pot and let them sit on the stove top while you peel the boiled eggs if you haven't already done them.

Chop the eggs up until the white pieces are very small. Chop the potatoes into small bite-sized pieces and add potatoes and chopped eggs to a large mixing bowl.

In a smaller bowl, mix sweet pickle juice, mayonnaise, sour cream, yellow mustard, salt, pepper, and celery seeds together and pour over the potatoes and eggs while they are still warm. I repeat, the eggs and potatoes will absorb the flavors so much better when they're still a bit warm.


Stir to mix the dressing in very well, Cover and let them sit while you chop and measure out everything else. Mix it all in a bowl large enough to hold everything before adding the mixture to the potatoes and eggs.

Gently stir everything together, then cover and refrigerate until time to serve. If you have the means to do so at the serving site, keep it as cold as possible, because your salad has eggs and mayonnaise in it, and either can go bad almost before you know it.

Cover and refrigerate all leftovers. It's even better the next day, and because it is, I will often make it the day before anyway. It's nice and cold then and full of the best flavor.

Source: This is the same recipe that my favorite aunt always made for our family get-togethers. I never eat potato salad anywhere that I don't think of her, and how sweet and loving she was to everyone.

By Julia from Boca Raton, FL

June 3, 20110 found this helpful

Sour cream? Sounds like a good add in. This I'll try. Thanks for another winner.


ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
June 3, 20110 found this helpful

I have one word for this recipe. Yum! It's a little differently made, but that's half the fun of cooking. Love your source, too.

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
June 3, 20110 found this helpful

Our big holiday for cookouts has always been July 4th. Our whole street gets involved and we do a pot luck with the fellas grouping together and cooking all the meats on the BBQ grills. They'll do chicken legs and half breasts, hot dogs and hamburgers and sometimes ribs or steaks. Anyway, everyone gets in on the fun and the work.

This year, we will be doing it all on Sunday, the 3rd since everyone is off from work and they can all take part. We'll save the firework watching for Monday, July 4 and just have ice-cream and cake then.

You couldn't have picked a better time to post this Potato Salad Pookarina. It sounds so much like the one my grandmother made, so this is what I'm making for our July 3 cookout this year.

Thank you for another delicious sounding recipe.


ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
June 3, 20110 found this helpful

Yum! This sounds so good, my stomach is growling! I was just asking my mom to remind me how she always made hers because I want to make it for my kids. I used to make it, but I've been so lazy about buying it, my 13 year old has never had it homemade & doesn't know what he's missing! And I forgot everything myself!Neither of us ever measured the ingredients for the dressing either, so you've given me a good basis to go on - and I like the idea of the sour cream,bet it tastes better!

Your recipe sounds very similar to my mom's, except she didn't use sour cream & she added dill pickle juice to help thin out the dressing. I always thought it was odd that she used sweet pickle relish, but added dill pickle juice, but she said it helped cut the sweetness of the relish. When I asked her why she didn't just add more mustard, she said she like the taste of the dill juice better!

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
June 3, 20110 found this helpful

Sounds really good, and the sauce sounds yummy! I love potato salad, and like trying different versions. I like the addition of the fresh parsley for flavor and nutrients. I also like the use of red onion for the color and taste. Thank you for posting this!

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
June 3, 20110 found this helpful

I don't remember what all my mum put in her potato salad, but this sounds close enough to suit me. I don't remember ever eating a potato salad that I didn't like. I think every good cook has their own version.

I like yours because you took the time to give good instructions, and I thank you for sharing your recipe.


ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
June 9, 20110 found this helpful

I have 2 children who are allergic to eggs, so do you think I could maybe substitute something like mozzarella cheese cut small instead of the eggs? This recipe sounds so good, so wholesome that I would like to try the cheese.

Thank you for help.


ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
June 11, 20110 found this helpful

Thank you to everyone who left such nice feedback. I wish you good luck with your salad.

Suziq9, since the texture of mozzarella is very similar to boiled egg whites, I don't think it'd hurt to try the cheese in the salad. It's also bland enough that I don't think you'll taste all that much difference. All you can do is try. That's kinda what Home Cooking is all about.

Tweaking, substituting one ingredient for another and changing it to suit your own family's needs and tastes. That's the difference in Home Cooking and Commercial type cooking, and that's what makes it so good, and why we call it "comfort food".

Let us know how the mozzarella cheese turns out. I for one would really like to know. It might be something that we could use when we plan using Potato salad on a picnic for instance where eggs can sometimes pose a problem. Excellent question.

Good luck to you too.


ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
June 13, 20110 found this helpful

Just wanted to let you know I used your potato salad recipe & my mom's recipe that I can remember, to create my own. I used the Idaho potatoes we always used & the dill pickle juice.I added the sour cream, since we always only used mayo. I had to just about double the ingredients for the dressing, maybe because of the different potato,it was way too dry. The sour cream is a huge improvement, we really loved it!

Wonderful! My whole family loved it !Except my 13 year old, who hates anything with boiled egg, next time I'll hold some egg-free back for him, LOL! My youngest 2 (16 & 13) have never had my homemade potato salad, but they'll sure be getting it a lot more now! I remembered as I was making this, why I quit making it. It's so hard on my hands, with carpal tunnel, tendinitis & arthritis. By the end of the day, my wrist ached & was swollen. But I think I have enough volunteers who can stir for me now & save my hands!

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
November 6, 20150 found this helpful

Our tastes in potato salad differ. We are in agreement on one thing, though. I have everything peeled, chopped, sliced, drained, measured, etc., ahead of time. As soon as the boiling water is drained from the potatoes, they are put into a large bowl. All other ingredients are then added to the still very hot potatoes. This causes a delicious melding of flavors you wont get any other way.

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes

Add your voice! Click below to comment. ThriftyFun is powered by your wisdom!

In This Article
Classic Potato Salad
Food and Recipes Recipes Salads PotatoJune 2, 2011
Sweet Potato Chips
Sweet Potato Chip Recipes
Potato Salad Dressing
Potato Salad Dressing Recipes
Hot Potato Salad
Hot Potato Salad Recipes
Halloween Ideas!
Ask a Question
Share a Post
You are viewing the desktop version of this page: View Mobile Site
© 1997-2016 by Cumuli, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Published by . Page generated on October 20, 2016 at 4:07:16 PM on in 4 seconds. Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of ThriftyFun's Disclaimer and Privacy Policy. If you have any problems or suggestions feel free to Contact Us.
Loading Something Awesome!