Increases in home heating costs have helped develop a market for portable kerosene heaters to provide localized or emergency heat for homes, cottages and service buildings. Many questions are being asked about the safety of these units. This publication answers typical questions and suggests practices to follow when using a portable unvented kerosene heater.
Questions and Answers
#1 How safe are the new unvented portable kerosene heaters?
That depends upon who you talk to. Some public health and safety officials take a cautious view of these types of heaters. Some manufacturers and dealers, however, do not. But it is a fact that these types of heaters can be a potential fire hazard and that the pollutants these heaters produce may represent a significant health hazard.
For these reasons, some communities and some states have banned the use of these types of heaters in homes. Would-be buyers of unvented, portable kerosene heaters should check with building authorities and/or fire officials and insurance representatives first.
If this type of heater is purchased, be sure to follow the manufacturer's exact directions for operation.
#2 What are some of the hazards of using unvented, portable kerosene heaters?
This type of heater:
#3 Are there portable, unvented kerosene heaters on the market that do not produce these gases?
No. Any heating system that burns fuel, and does not have a chimney, will give off some gases into the room or area where it operates.
#4 Is there an accumulative "indoor pollution hazard" from use of several unvented appliances?
It would appear so, especially in a "weatherized" home or a unventilated room.
Following tests of 18 types of portable, unvented heaters, Consumer Reports states that: "We calculated the concentration of four gases produced by these heaters - carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, and sulphur dioxide - in a 10x12x8-foot room with normal ventilation. The levels of each gas were high enough to be a serious health hazard to high-risk groups, including pregnant women, asthmatics, people with cardiovascular disease, children, and the elderly. The levels we calculated for some pollutants may pose risks for healthy people."
Hazard from indoor pollution is highest on calm days when an unvented heater is used along with an unvented gas range, gas refrigerator and a gas clothes dryer; along with a vented water heater and furnace. Only heating units connected to chimneys exhaust products of combustion safely to the outside of the home.
#5 Of the gases that are produced by a portable, unvented heater, which is potentially the most lethal?
Carbon monoxide. It is toxic because it interferes with the blood's ability to carry oxygen to the cells of the body. It may reach toxic levels in the blood stream within minutes or several hours. Carbon monoxide may be a particular threat to persons with heart ailments.
Early carbon monoxide poisoning symptoms include dizziness, headache, weakness, drowsiness and/or nausea. Some people could experience impaired judgement and irritability.
#6 Why is carbon monoxide so deadly?
Carbon monoxide replaces oxygen in the blood until suffocation occurs. Carbon monoxide mixes with your blood 210 times quicker than oxygen, so even getting fresh air after poisoning symptoms begin may not help and suffocation can still occur. It takes from 10 to 24 hours to rid the blood of excessive carbon monoxide.
#7 Do I really have to open a window one inch or keep a door ajar to another room to maintain a margin of safety while using a portable, unvented kerosene heater?
Yes, especially if the heater is located in a room having less than 150 square feet. Be sure to read the manufacturer's instructions about ventilation. The Consumer Product Safety Commission recommends one square inch of open window in the room where the heater is being used for each 1,000 Btu of the heater's rated output.
For example, if the heater is rated at 9,100 Btu per hour, and the window in the room is 24 inches wide, the window should be opened almost one-half inch. If the heater is rated at 20,000 Btu, that window should be open almost 1 inch.
Obviously, this causes a loss of heat, but it should help provide adequate ventilation provided that the portable heater is operating at manufacturer's specifications.
#8 What grade or quality of kerosene should be used?
Use ONLY 1-K grade of kerosene in portable, unvented heaters.
Kerosene is generally retailed in two grades - 1-K, which is low in sulfur (.04 percent sulfur by weight) and 2-K, which is much higher in sulfur. Use of 2-K grade kerosene will dramatically increase sulfur dioxide emissions. Using kerosene other than the 1-K grade may increase health risk.
However, finding 1-K grade kerosene may be difficult. just because a kerosene dealer says that the grade of kerosene is "water-clear" or "clear white" does not mean it is the 1-K grade. Both grades can look clear. Find a dealer who can certify that what is being sold is 1-K grade kerosene.
#9 What happens if other fuels are substituted in place of 1-K kerosene?
The risk of a fire or an explosion increases dramatically. In March 1982, the Consumer Product Safety Commission and the National Kerosene Heater Association warned against using gasoline in kerosene heaters, citing a number of serious injuries and deaths from such use.
Other fuels, such as diesel or jet "A" fuel, may be equally dangerous.
#10 What about storing 1-K grade kerosene?
Storage of any type of liquid fuel requires a certain amount of care and common sense. All kerosene should be stored in a metal fuel container clearly marked KEROSENE. Paint the container green, or some color other than red, so that it will not be accidently confused with a container of gasoline.
Don't store kerosene in an old gasoline can. This will prevent getting it mixed up with gasoline and inadvertently putting gasoline in the heater. Store kerosene out of the home in a well-ventilated and cool area, away from where children play.
#11 What safer choices do I have for spot or localized heating inside my home?
Portable electrical heaters may also be used to conserve energy if used to briefly warm persons in one part of the house instead of turning on the furnace. Use portable electric heaters rated no higher than 1500 watts to avoid overloading ordinary outlets in the home. Check for the "U.L. listed" statement on the nameplate before buying. Radiant heat types (quartz-nichrome wire enclosed in clear tubes) are more efficient in providing warmth to persons within 3 to 10 feet, without heating the entire room.
#12 Is it cheaper to use a portable kerosene heater or a portable electric heater for spot heating my home?
It costs about the same to operate either heater when your electrical rate is 5 cents per kilowatt hour and yo can buy 1-K grade kerosene for $2 per gallon. A gallon of 1-K kerosene has a Btu equivalence of approximately 40 kilowatt hours. (135,000 Btu and 3,413 Btu/KwHr). To estimate operating costs, multiply your actual cost per kilowatt hour by 40 to determine what you could pay for 1-K kerosene per gallon to produce the same number of Btu's. In addition, consider comparative purchase prices of electric and kerosene haters, maintenance costs of both, convenience and related factors. For example, the operating costs provided above for kerosene units does not allow for the heat lost by slightly opening a window for ventilation, as recommended by the Consumer Product Safety Commission and most manufacturers. Neither is allowance made for costs new electrical outlets or circuits that might be needed for a portable electrical heater.
#13 Should I use a portable, unvented kerosene heater in my home?
While the choice is clearly yours, consider this:
Precautions and Suggestions on Use
A portable kerosene heater can be used during waking hours to take the chill off an area without starting up the central heating system. Its temporary use can help remove dampness in a basement or vacation cottage, and help provide working comfort in a garage, construction site or storage area if adequate ventilation exists. A gas or unvented portable kerosene heater has value for TEMPORARY use during a power failure, especially in remote areas.
This information comes from Michigan State University Extension bulletin E-1669, Some Considerations About Portable Kerosene Heaters.
I have used these kerosene heaters for many years while living in the arctic and away from the electrical grid. They are excellent for heating up generator shacks, SMALL garages, small workshops, and to keep propane tanks functioning below -40, IF you have no electricity.
Forget about using them inside a well insulated home unless you are very suicidal. Even if you plan to keep a window open and throw expensive heat out, somebody will sooner or later close that window.
In garages, generator shacks, and propane shacks they can be fuelled with furnace oil (Diesel without road tax). Kerosene is ridiculously expensive.
IF you have electricity, then there are lots of much cheaper ways to heat. A regular oil furnace that uses cheap heating oil is usually the most economic way to heat.
Kerosene heaters are very expensive to operate and have only two advantages:
1) No need for electricity
2) They produce less water vapor than propane and less rust on cold machinery.