Gardening > FlowersOctober 28, 2008

Winterizing Roses

In winterizing roses, do they have to be confined by cones. I am tempted to try hilling alone and wish to use shredded leaves mixed with top soil. Does this make sense? Also, I would like to cut up cross sections of paper leaf bags to act as restraining devices for the leaf/soil mix. Any advice gratefully received.

Hardiness Zone: 5a

Jim from Detroit, MI

By

Answers

Read answers for this post below.

By mklema92658 (Guest Post) 11/22/2008

I'm not sure what the cones are you are referring to but what about using tomato cages upside down and wrapping them with paper? Fill up with leaves and mulch to the top. Just a thought.

By Elaine (Guest Post) 10/30/2008

Jim, I think that is what most experts recommend you do instead of the cones. The soil and leaves will do a better job of insulating than the cones. The problem with the cones is that you have to remove them at just the right time. Another problem that I have with them is that are never large enough. I don't want to be pruning at this time of the year as that promotes growth .If you remove the cones too soon you risk injury. Do it too late and the roses suffer from not getting the sunlight. I usually just mound the dirt myself, without any leaves but it could not hurt to use the leaves. I see you are in Michigan so I imagine you are in zone 4 or 5 as I am. Don't know about using the paper, never tried that.

By
10/28/2008

I am debating that same issue right now. I will probalby do the cones, as I'd rather be safe than sorry with two new rose bushes and three older ones that have done well this year. Here's more on protecting roses.

http://www.oldhouseweb.com/gardening/roses-winter-protection.shtml

Related

Answer this Question

Your thoughts are welcomed and appreciated. Enter your answer here!

Answer:

Image Upload:

Add an image to your post! Click the "Browse" button above and select an image from your hard drive. Please only select gifs or jpegs. If you have any problems, please contact us.

  

facebook like arrowLike ThriftyFun on Facebook

Browse Topics

Over 80,000 tips, recipes, questions & crafts.

Ask a Question

Submit a question to the TF community.

Subscribe to ThriftyFun Newsletters!

Email: