Favors for Church Christmas Dinner

I was going to suggest the same thing as Southern Saver. Candles would be ideal. You could get a box of a dozen or so taper candles at a hobby craft store and there are pretty rhinestone stickers or silver and gold stickers that are made to decorate candles with. Not sure how many you are having to do though. You can also get a large bag of tea light candles for next to nothing at Walmart or the hobby store and you could find small paper sacks to decorate or punch holes in for the light to shine out when the candle is placed inside (similar to the ones done for Halloween).

Sound like the perfect occasion for candles!