Saving Money on Eggs

Tips for saving money on eggs as suggested by the ThriftyFun community.

Eggs in Recipes

I've noticed when baking something if the recipe calls for three eggs, I can usually get away with just putting in 2. If it calls for 2 egg whites, I usually just put one whole egg. Everything still turns out the same.


By Melanie

Keep Chickens In the Backyard

If you have a reasonable sized back garden (yard), and your local government allows, keep 2-4 chickens depending on the size of your family. You will have eggs galore, enough for all your needs and some to give to friends, family and neighbors.

The added bonuses are they will use up all your kitchen scraps instead of putting them through a waste disposal system and overloading the sewage plant or sending them to landfill. You will have the chicken wastes to use on the garden, (a very rich fertilizer), and they can be moved around in a mobile bottomless pen to do your garden weeding.

If you get a placid variety, they also make good pets for children, and if you get all the same color and one dies, you can pop another one in without the children noticing.


My favorites are ex-battery hens which are very placid and easy to pick up for a pet and you also have the satisfaction of giving them a happy life after the living hell of a battery cage. The last benefit I can think of, (there are probably many more!), is that you know exactly what goes into your eggs - no antibiotics and other drugs, etc.

P.S. You don't need a noisy old rooster either!

By Jo

Cook "By The Book" Before Making Changes

Be careful changing the number of eggs in a recipe. Many things need all the eggs they call for, and many recipes calling for egg whites seriously don't need the yokes. I usually (though not always) cook 'by the book' the first time and then decide what changes I can get away with.

By Alph

Menu Planning

The only thing I can think of to say to this topic is always serve something else with it if you are having eggs. For example, if you do scrambled eggs, do some toast with it. It adds sustenance.


A great recipe I find is for French toast. Supposedly you should beat 3 eggs and add a drop of milk to make enough mixture for 4 slices. I always use one egg and add extra milk and it turns out just as nice, especially if you sprinkle a little bit of sugar and lemon on top!

By Triona

Buy Eggs Locally

Check with local farmers or your local Amish/Mennonite community. They will often sell eggs for a lot cheaper then you can get at the store. They may be brown, but don't let the color fool you, they are just as yummy on the inside! You also get the benefit of having healthier food. The "free range" eggs are better on the chickens and better for you (as they are not "processed").

By Qryztufre

Substitutes For Eggs

I was going to suggest getting a couple of chickens, but I see Jo already did that. I will just give you substitutions instead; you can use these in place of our added to stretch your eggs. Here are some substitutes:

  • banana = 1 egg in cakes.
  • 2 tbsp corn starch = 1 egg
  • 2 tbsp arrowroot flour = 1 egg
  • 2 tbsp potato starch = 1 egg
  • 1 heaping tbsp soy powder + 2 tbsp water = 1 egg
  • 1 tbsp soy milk powder + 1 tbsp cornstarch + 2 tbsp water = 1

Egg, 1 whole (3 tablespoons or 1.7 oz):

  • 2 1/2 tablespoons of powdered egg substitute plus 2 1/2 tablespoons water
  • or 1/4 cup liquid egg substitute
  • or 1/4 cup silken tofu pureed
  • or 3 tablespoons mayonnaise
  • or half a banana mashed with 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
  • or 1 tablespoon powdered flax seed soaked in 3 tablespoons water

By Babbie

Stretch With Milk

There's always the tip that when you are scrambling eggs, "soft" scramble them. Add milk (powdered works fine), you can adjust the amount of milk you add to suit your tastes and/or to how far you need to stretch them.

By Bailegirl

Check Convenience Stores

Eggs are cheaper here at the Mobil mart than at the grocery store and for X-large eggs too!

By Kladybug

Urban Chickens

I know someone already suggested getting chickens and I wanted to tell you that I highly recommend it! When my husband suggested that we get some I thought he was crazy because we lived in a neighborhood right off one of the busiest roads in the capital city of our state and I just knew that the neighbors would complain like mad about the stench and the noise but he was so excited about it that I gave in and I'm so glad I did! I was surprised at just how easy they are to care for!

They don't stink at all because we use what's known as a deep litter system. That's basically just keeping fresh straw in their coop for them to poop on and then when they scratch, they turn under their waste and you don't even smell it! Just keep adding straw. 3 or 4 times a year, just empty out the coop and use the litter in your garden or find a friend who gardens and give it to them as it's one of the best fertilizers money can buy.

As for the noise, it's also not a problem. You really don't hear them and the noises they make are cute, not obnoxious. We took all our neighbors fresh eggs occasionally, and as a result got to know the people living around us and made some new friends and not one of them even knew the chickens were there so they had no complaints!

We worked out a deal with a natural grocery where they give us all the produce they were going to throw out (it's all organic too!) to feed to the girls so the majority of their food is free and the organic food makes the eggs taste better!

This is by far the way to go to get more eggs, especially if you have kids! Give them the responsibility of the chickens since it's so easy and fun! They'll love the fact that eggs can not only be white and brown but one breed even lays blue and Dr. Suess green!

Since the ladies came into our lives and our friends have actually seen how great and easy to care for they are, 3 of them have already added some chickens to their backyard and one is getting some tomorrow. It seems we started some kind of urban chicken movement where we live!

Anyway, I know this post is long, thanks for reading and good luck!

By Mandalyn

Country Eggs Taste Better

We began buying eggs from someone locally that raises chickens and sells eggs. I could not believe how much better they taste too. They are much richer tasting, and sometimes even doubled yolk. For a while, eggs were getting really high, and she could beat the grocery prices, but, when they went down, she is about the same in price now. But, it's a much better egg, taste and healthy wise, and I prefer to pay the price. And think of all the additives that you can miss like this.

My "egg lady" is very particular and clean with her chickens. Always make sure this is the case. It shows in the taste of the egg, and the expense of it. I druther get eggs like this than raise my own chickens, I also live in the country, and could. But, it pays to have my "egg lady" to do it. The eggs taste so good, my teens that hated eggs, love these good country rich eggs.

By Glinda

More Eggs Substitutions

If your recipe calls for 3 eggs, use 2 + 1 tablespoon oil, 2 tablespoons of water, and 2 teaspoons of dried egg white or meringue powder.

By Nance

Another Vote For Chickens

You can, as you see, stretch your eggs, and the flaxseed substitute works really well. I have chickens myself. A lot of towns will allow people to have hens but no roosters. Not a problem as you don't need a rooster to get the hens to lay eggs. I'd call your town clerk's office and ask if you can have hens. They LOVE kitchen scraps and they'll help rid your yard of bugs. There are a lot of nice designs for little movable chicken coops too.

Hens are really nice to have. I love my chickens. We feed them cracked corn and kitchen scraps, they also get all the greenery when we weed gardens and all the gone over produce when we thin the fruit trees and other stuff.

By Shosha

Hard Boiled Eggs Tips

Put toothpick in water and you'll never have a cracked egg again.

By Rosie

Feel free to post your ideas for saving money on eggs below!

March 28, 20080 found this helpful

The most obvious way to save money on eggs is to buy in bulk 2 1/2 dozen. One store may charge $4.99 and another store can charge $3.99. One carton of eggs is usually over $2 these days!

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
March 28, 20080 found this helpful

I saw that Triona says 3 eggs for 4 pieces of french toast. I often get away with one egg for two pieces of toast. First, I put three eggs in the blender, add about a tablespoon of cooking oil, , a little vanilla, a touch of cinnamon and about 2 teaspoons of sugar. Turn on the blender and it whips the eggs up. The added oil helps prevent sticking to the pan. The eggs make more toast because they have air whipped into them. The french toast is lighter. My family loves it this way.

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
March 29, 20080 found this helpful

I disagree with advice for everyone to keep chickens in the yard or a homemade coop to provide eggs for their family. Give it more consideration than a suggestion that sounds good. We are talking about living things that require care 365 days a year, our attention to their safety and health.

Since this H5N1 virus is transmitted (currently) from bird to bird and has been known to be carried to otherwise unexposed flocks by migrating wild birds, keeping poultry just to save money on eggs probably isn't sound advice. It is a particularly bad idea for people to let their poultry "free range" for food and risk possible exposure to carriers of all manner of illnesses in the wild population.

Chickens need grains, they need grit, they need clean water and shelter. They need to be protected from the elements as well as natural enemies and torment of neighboring animals as well as others who might want to see if the chickens will eat this or that. The internet is full of wicked suggestions particularly regarding birds and we all know how cruel a child's curiosity can be.

Keeping a flock of any size requires a little more thought and effort than throwing some grains in the yard and providing water.

Chickens are at the bottom of the food chain. They have very little means of self-defense and have limited flying ability. There are predators to consider; snakes are very hard to fence out and are very fond of eggs, themselves; hawks and other birds of prey that will consider the chickens a tasty meal.

What will you do about your feather family members when your family wants to go on vacation? They need to be considered as pets and provided for because that's what they are when kept in the city.

Keeping chickens is not for everyone. I have been a commercial poultry farmer (cageless & free range) in the past as well as keeping a backyard flock in the city. Still, I do not recommend this unless the folks that want to try it are aware they are also adopting/buying additional pets that need daily care. If you are not a "pet person," abandon the idea of keeping chickens to save a few dollars on eggs.

Instead, I would suggest folks buy freeze-dried or dehydrated eggs. When re-hydrated, they will not fool anyone and are less than appealing as scrambled, but are equal to normal eggs when used in recipes calling for them. The best place I've found is ... p?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=631 One 2.5 # can is equal to 85+ eggs and is non perishable. You can buy whole eggs, all white or all yolks to reduce waste when making recipes calling for one component or the other.

Otherwise, continue to buy eggs for your french toast from your store or someone who does keep chickens.

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
March 29, 20080 found this helpful

We have chickens and it is common to get a double yolked egg. Today, I got my first "triple yolked" egg.

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
March 30, 20080 found this helpful

Keeping chickens is a good idea, but keep some things in mind before you get a flock. First, make sure you have a sturdy coop. If not, the raccoons and dogs will get them. Have a fenced off space for them as they will ruin your yard. Feed them commercial grain every day, not just scraps or they won't lay. Please don't give them meat scraps as it make them very aggressive. And remember that you don't need a rooster to get eggs.

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
March 31, 20080 found this helpful

I know of no case where chickens not kept under factory-farm conditions have spread bird flu, H5N1, to humans. There are many cases where the factory-bred sort, unhealthy to start with and with much poorer eggs, have been transmitters, mostly (so far) in East Asia.

Also, a recent pair of articles in Mother Earth News (I think available online) show eggs from hens living free are both more nutritious (including omega-3s!) and more plentiful.

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes
April 2, 20080 found this helpful

I have always used the formula for purchasing eggs, which is, if the difference in price is 8 cents or less between large and extra large, I buy the extra large.

Has anyone else ever heard of this?

ReplyWas this helpful?Helpful? Yes

Add your voice! Click below to comment. ThriftyFun is powered by your wisdom!

In This Article
A pile of brown chicken eggs.
Saving Money on Eggs
Food and Recipes Food Tips EggsMarch 28, 2008
empty egg carton
Substitution For Eggs in Recipes
Scrambled eggs are too watery.
Watery Scrambled Eggs
Cooking eggs for a large group.
Cooking Scrambled Eggs for a Large Group
Reusing Plastic Easter Eggs
Reusing Plastic Easter Eggs
Halloween Ideas!
Ask a Question
Share a Post
You are viewing the desktop version of this page: View Mobile Site
© 1997-2016 by Cumuli, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Published by . Page generated on October 22, 2016 at 7:27:17 AM on in 2 seconds. Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of ThriftyFun's Disclaimer and Privacy Policy. If you have any problems or suggestions feel free to Contact Us.
Loading Something Awesome!