Food Tips & Info > SubstitutionsDecember 11, 2009

Substituting Butter for Shortening When Baking

Can butter be substituted for shortening in a sweet bread recipe?

By Della

Answers

Read answers for this post below.

By
12/14/2009

Yes but be aware that it might slightly change the taste or texture depending on what you're cooking or baking. Here's the rule of thumb substitution:

1 cup shortening equals 1 cup butter minus 1/2 teaspoon salt from the recipe.

If you're asking for substitution for skillet type cooking please keep in mind that butter has a much lower burning point than shortening.

By
12/14/2009

I never use shortening in any of my baking for health reasons, because shortening is high in trans fats. I use olive oil and my sweet breads turn out fine (banana bread, pumpkin bread, date & nut loaf, etc). If using butter, I would suggest unsalted butter, or if using regular (salted) butter, reduce the salt in your recipe by 1/8 teaspoon.

By
12/12/2009

Yes, good luck.

Questions

Here are questions related to this page. Click "Ask a Question" if you have a question to ask about this topic.

When to Use Shortening?

When a recipe calls for shortening in cookies, bars, cake, etc., how do you know if they really mean shortening, as in Crisco, or if butter can be used?

By BonnieAlice

 

Most Recent Answer

By redhatterb 01/21/2012

I don't know if Crisco still makes it, but for awhile they made butter flavored Crisco, and at that time I started substituting margarine for the Crisco, that way I only had to buy one product. I haven't done any baking for years unless I use mixes, and that isn't real often as I am a type 2 diabetic.

Substituting Butter or Oil for Shortening

I am using gluten free Bisquick to make biscuits and it calls for 1/3 cup of shortening. Can I substitute butter or oil instead and if so what would be the equivalent measure?
Thank you for any info.

By Deanna G

 

Most Recent Answer

By Deeli 07/13/2011

You can but it might change the density and flavor of many original recipes. Switching won't make a huge difference in most recipes but it can mean the difference between a moist or dry cake.

Related

Answer this Question

Your thoughts are welcomed and appreciated. Enter your answer here!

Answer:

Image Upload:

Add an image to your post! Click the "Browse" button above and select an image from your hard drive. Please only select gifs or jpegs. If you have any problems, please contact us.

  

facebook like arrowLike ThriftyFun on Facebook

Browse Topics

Over 80,000 tips, recipes, questions & crafts.

Ask a Question

Submit a question to the TF community.

Subscribe to ThriftyFun Newsletters!

Email: