Toilet Leaking Even After Replacing Seal

By BeanTownSteve (Guest Post)

In thinking a little more, additional settling to the house MAY have "raised" (again relative to the floor) the ring/waste connection. Still the same suggestion.

By BeanTownSteve (Guest Post)

If you've had renovation done in the bathroom and/or replaced the floor, it may be that the floor ring is not longer at the right height relative to the floor and the wax seal is no longer exactly making a proper seal.
A qualified plumber should be able to check this easily but it may have been overlooked if it's "close".

By

Noella

I had this happen - to the point that I replaced the bathroom floor - twice! Turned out that the commode actually had a hairline crack in it. The man who installed it new had tightened the commode too tight. So what had happened was I'd replaced the floor, installed the new commode, but he cracked it. The crack didn't show up for a couple of years. In the meantime it had been slowly leaking under the floor vinyl. The man who installed it was a friend, so I couldn't go back and have him reimburse me - I just had to "eat" the cost of doing it over.

By

maxboots1

Check the seals, on each side, where the tank connects to the bowl.
Twice we replaced the seal where the bowl meets the floor, turns out it was the seal inside the tank, between the tank and that chimmey thingy, sorry can't think of the correct term.
We really thought the water was coming from under the bowl and it wasn't.
:)

By

Cajun62234

Obviously, if the drain were cleaned out, there would not be a blockage... can you ask a different plumber to investigate? Do you know a Mech. (Plumbing) Designer/Engineer that will stop by the house and evaluate as a 'friend'?
What about roots in the pipe? You can pour some food coloring (blue or red) into the toilet tank...see if you can notice any exterior leakage... (there is also a Bluing in the Laundry Section of the grocery store....used to help whiten clothing)