Crafts, Recipes, Tips,
& Guides
Enter Contests
Share & Vote
Get Advice
Submit a

Trouble With Pampered Chef Cookie Press

0 0EmailPrintFollow

Can somebody tell me what I'm doing wrong before I have a temper tantrum and break my cookie press? I have a Pampered Chef press and I lost the directions in a recent move. I've tried using another recipe I found and it's not working. I either literally blow the plunger end off the thing (dough too cold?) or when it comes out the other end it won't come off.

I have to manually scoop it off which ruins the design. I'm not even sure which end of the design plate goes out. There is a difference in the sides of it. I've only used it one other time several years ago and remember having trouble then but finally figured it out. However, this year I'm older and less patient or something. Can somebody please help me?

Judi from Elgin



Recent Answers

Here are the recent answer to this question.

By Chef Donna (Guest Post)12/22/2008

I have good news! You can obtain the Product Information insert for any current Pampered Chef product at Look for PRODUCTS, then locate the cookie press.
If this link works, just click it, then print. I hope this helps! ... oheaders/printable.jsp?productId=600

By Judi [17]12/15/2008

Thanks everybody for the help and offers of help. I've survived Thanksgiving without cookie press cookies and now have my Christmas cookies already in the freezer so I'm not going to be making anymore this year...maybe. I'll try some of these ideas next year but have about decided I don't want to make cookies that require so much effort. I like my drop choc. chip, oatmeal raisin, and peanut butter. I'm waaay too old to deal with the stress! Thanks again and Merry CHRISTmas!

By Tricia (Guest Post)12/12/2008

I know what it is, because once I figured it out, I've been fine and it works perfectly. Its your dough. The standard recipe is a box of white cake mix, 2 and 3/4 c. flour, you mix them together. Then use your hands and make a mound out of it and scoop out a volcano center. The most important thing is the butter. Its a pound of butter. Nuke 2 sticks until almost melted, or partially and stir them up. Then slice the other 2 sticks into pats and toss those into the melted butter. Keep stirring it around.

You cannot have the butter completely melted or solid. It should be just about the consistency of cake batter, so don't over nuke. Be patient the butter pats will melt into the other 2 sticks if you keep stirring. I've used my hands before to do it too. Ok so now you have a mound with a hole, and a bowl of not quite liquid, not quite solid butter. Pour the butter into the hole in the mound and use your hands to start mixing. Yes its messy. Take of your rings and if you have nice nails wear gloves. I keep kneading it until its silky smooth.

Sometimes if you cookie sheet is hot that will make it not want to stick too. Using these steps I never have a problem, and before that I was getting so peeved off and even threw out dough in anger. It's the consistency of the butter that is the single most important thing.

By Mary (Guest Post)11/20/2008

I've only used mine once so far, but I loved it. The person selling the stuff at the party I went to told me it was tricky to use the first few times and she was right- not all the discs worked properly for me, but enough did to give me some very professional looking cookies. I love to bake (and unfortunately to eat ) so always like something new. For a good recipe, try Company's Coming Spritz cookies (might be on their website

By Marg. England (Guest Post)11/20/2008

Give it away- life's too short!

By Leigh Ann (Guest Post)11/19/2008

Use and Care instuctions are available at under "products". This should take you straight to the Cookie Press Use and Care:

As for the end coming off, you are probably correct in thinking that perhaps the dough was too cold. It should be just about the consistency of playdough. The shape disks should be "number" side out.

Feel free to email me if you need further assistance. I will do my best for you! iamchef dot leighann at yahoo

By Judi [17]11/18/2008

Thanks MCW! After I sent this question in (on Saturday!) I spent some time googleing it and discovered I'm not the only one having this problem and many users are checking the "would not recommend" box. I sure don't like it. My kitchen gadgets are there to make things easier, not harder.

By Marjorie C. Woodworth [82]11/18/2008 ... ookie_Press_1525/content_95681089156

The two websites might answer a few of your questions, if not Google: Pampered Chef Cookie Press and see what you come up with.

Answer This Question

Add your voice to the conversation. Click here to answer this question.