Columnists > Ellen Brown > ArticlesApril 17, 2008

By Ellen Brown

Highly prized for its strength, resistance to decay, handsome wood grain, and product versatility (it's made into everything from furniture to airplane propellers) to woodworkers, Black Walnuts trees are considered black gold. To us gardeners, however, Black Walnuts trees can prove to be a difficult landscaping challenge.

Understanding Alleopathy

Black Walnut trees (Juglans nigra) are alleopathic, a term used to describe plant species that have beneficial or harmful chemical effects on other plants. In the case of Black Walnut trees, the allelopathic interaction is harmful. The toxin responsible is called juglone, and resides in large amounts in the tree's roots. Juglone is known to inhibit respiration, resulting in stunted or deformed growth, and even death, in juglone-sensitive plants. Related species such as the English walnut (Juglans regia) and Butternut (Juglans cinerea) tree are also alleopathic, although to a lesser extent.

Allelopathic interactions are complex and scientists are still conducting studies to fully understand the process.

Signs & Symptoms

Plants suffering from juglone toxicity may show a variety of symptoms. The extent of damage depends on the resistance of individual plants and the amount of contact with the toxin. It's believed that susceptible plants need to come within 1/4" - 1/2" proximity to the walnut tree's roots for serious damage to occur, but even a minor amount of contact with decaying leaf litter, nut husks or rain drops containing juglone is also thought to harm some extremely sensitive plants. Look for wilting, droopy, puckering, or twisting leaves that appear yellow or discolored. Internal stem tissues on woody plants or shrubs may also show darkening or discoloration.

Planting Strategies

Avoid Tree Removal: Cutting down your Black Walnut trees is not a good solution to your landscaping woes. At least not if your tree is healthy. Juglone is not very water soluble and will stay in the soil (and any tiny feeder roots not removed) for several years. Black Walnut trees provide wonderful shade, reduce CO2 while providing fresh oxygen, produce food and shelter for backyard wildlife and birds, and make an excellent windbreak due to the strength of their wood.

Create Some Distance: The roots of a large Black Walnut tree can extend far beyond the reaches of its canopy. There is no magic safe distance for planting, but suffice to say, the farther away the better. When in doubt, make sure you experiment with cheaper plants.

Growing In Containers: Many gardeners have found great success by growing susceptible plants above ground in attractive containers. This is your opportunity to get creative and experiment with different planters and containers.

Clean Up Tree Debris: Leaf litter and nut husks contain only very small concentrations of juglone, but it's better to play it safe than be sorry by keeping the area around your tree raked up and free from fallen debris. If trimmed branches or bark are shredded for mulch, be sure to use them only on juglone resistant plants.

Plants To Avoid Under or Near Black Walnut Trees

Plants from the nightshade family (Solanaceae) seem especially susceptible to the effects of juglone. This includes eggplants, cabbage, green peppers, potatoes, and tomatoes.

Other susceptible plants include: Azalea, rhododendron, cotoneaster, potentilla, apple, blackberry, blueberry, cucumber, grapes (domestic), crocus, peony, black alder (Alnus); basswood; white birches; Hopa crabapple; hackberry; Amur honeysuckle; Japanese larch; lespedeza; lilac; saucer magnolia; silver maple; mountain laurel; loblolly pine; red pine; scotch pine; white pine; privet; Norway spruce; and alfalfa.

Plants To Grow Under or Near Black Walnut Trees

There is a lot of conflicting information on which plants can be grown under Black Walnut trees. Plants on this list that require full sun can be grown near Black Walnut trees rather than beneath them. This list is meant as a general guide and it by no means complete (nor is the list above of plants to avoid). As stated earlier, allelopathic interactions are complex and your own experience may prove different depending on individual soil conditions, climate, etc. Plants on this list have either been specifically studied for their resistance to juglone or have been grown successfully under or near Black Walnut trees by fellow gardeners. As always, please feel free to comment on your own successes or failures so we can all learn!

Vegetables

Lima beans; snap beans; beets; carrots; corn; onions; melons; parsnips; and squash.

Landscape Plants

Red cedar; crabapple*; elm; winged euonymus; forsythia; hawthorn; hemlock; hickories; black locust; maples (most species); oaks; autumn olive; pachysandra; paw paw; persimmon; wild rose; sycamore; most viburnums; and Virginia creeper.

Fruits

Cherries and black raspberries

Flowers and Herbaceous Plants

Astilbe; bee balm; wax begonia; bellflower; bloodroot; bluebells; Kentucky bluegrass; coral bells; cranesbill; crocus*' daffodil; Shasta daisy; daylily; Dutchman's britches; ferns; fescue; hollyhock; glory-of-the-snow; hosta; iris; Jack-in-the-pulpit; lamb's ear; liriope; lungwort; pansies; pot marigold; morning glory; narcissus; phlox; sedum; Siberian squill; snowdrop; spiderwort; spring beauty; sundrops; sweet woodruff; trillium; violets; and zinnia.

* Conflicting information available so it appears on both lists.

About The Author: Ellen Brown is an environmental writer and photographer and the owner of Sustainable Media, an environmental media company that specializes in helping businesses and organizations promote eco-friendly products and services. Contact her on the web at http://www.sustainable-media.com

Post Feedback

Read feedback for this post below.

• Is Black Walnut Tree Toxic To Sweetspire Plant?
• Selling Walnut Trees
• Curing Black Walnuts

• Plants That Can Survive Near a Black Walnut Tree
• What Will Grow Under Walnut Trees?
• Getting Rid of Walnut Trees