Share on ThriftyFunThis page contains the following solutions. Have something to add? Please share your solution!
I am forever thinking I have something when I don't! It's easy to mix up this substitution for ground allspice.
This is a good substitute for allspice when you don't have it but allspice is it's own spice. From Wikipedia: "Allspice is the dried fruit of the P. dioica plant. The fruit are picked when green and unripe and are traditionally dried in the sun. When dry, they are brown and resemble large brown peppercorns. The whole fruit have a longer shelf life than the powdered product and produce a more aromatic product when freshly ground before use."
To make 1 teaspoon of allspice, simply mix the following:
Editor's Note: Although this blend tastes similar to allspice, it is not exactly the same. Allspice grows in the Caribbean and looks similar to peppercorns. Here is a ThriftyFun article about this unusual spice.
Well, now you know, Jackie. Allspice is given it's name due to the fact it tastes like a combination of other spices. I don't know that the nutmeg helped bring the concoction closer to an allspice taste, though.
I prefer allspice over cinnamon in lots of dishes, candied yams, for one. It is a potent spice, usually one quarter teaspoon or less is enough for the average dish.