Share on ThriftyFunThis guide contains the following solutions. Have something to add? Please share your solution!
This is a very easy recipe.
Total Time: 20 minutes
Yield: 16 cookies
This recipe was from radio station Magic 98 in Madison, WI.
This recipe is simple and easy clean up.
By Fred from Lincoln Park, MI
Ask a QuestionHere are the questions asked by community members. Read on to see the answers provided by the ThriftyFun community or ask a new question.
The other night I had a boxed spice cake mix but no oil or eggs. My cupboards were pretty bare. The box called for 1/3 cup oil and 3 eggs. I had some mayonnaise and used 1 cup of it, 1/2 tsp of baking powder and about a Tbsp of sugar. I baked it for the same length of time recommended on the box. The cake turned out amazingly well and I'd definitely do this again in a pinch.
By Aimee Valle from Bellaire, OH
The BEST cake ever is a plain box mix with a can of DIET soda. No eggs or oil. Just the mix and a diet soda. It turns out very moist and the options are endless. Not to mention its healthier for you. Try it, youll be amazed.
How about a orange cake mix w/ 7up or sprite?
A chocolate cake with cherry coke?
White cake with cream soda?
Endless possibilities. Cake does come out pretty dense and crumbles a bit easier, be prepared for that :)!
And, btw, mayo in brownies substituted for eggs is amazing. It dont sound too pleasant but it works wonders and there no mayo taste like in your cake.
I've been wanting to try the can of diet soda in a cake, but the trouble is I didn't have any of that either, I just had mayonnaise and ketchup in the fridge. It was great being able to use up the mayo and get a cake out of the deal and I didn't have to go hungry that night!
Some World War 2 recipes would also be egg and oil free.
Substituting mayo for the oil in a cake works because the main ingredient in mayo IS oil (plus egg, spices and lemon juice &/or vinegar).As long as the flavoring in the cake over-rides the spices in the mayo you should be ok. A little extra flour plus some baking powder could substitute for eggs in a pinch. Good for you for being resourceful!
If you are trying to make a recipe that doesn't include eggs, using mayonnaise is like using eggs but just in a different form. Someone like myself need recipes that contain no eggs, and mayonnaise is not a good substitute.
Hi, I am a vegetarian! I don't want to use eggs in baking and other cooking because the chickens are treated horribly. I would like recipes for cakes, cookies, other desserts, scones, breads, and main courses that can be made successfully without eggs. (Of course, no meat or broth from animals either.) I do use cheese. Thanks! :)
Michelle from Bethlehem, PA
I have been told that I can no longer have eggs (really high cholesterol levels). I love to bake and a lot of the recipes call for eggs. I know I can use egg whites only but have no idea how many to use them. If the recipe calls for 1 egg, how many whites do I use? Also, what about liquid egg substitutes? Are they good for baking or just for making scrambled "eggs"?
Thanks, Darlene in Mississauga, Ontario Canada
Go to a bulk store and buy soy flour. One heaping Tbsp. and a Tbsp. of water makes a substitution for one egg. I've used in cookies, bread, cake, muffins, etc, no problems (02/20/2006)
Hi Darlene, I use the egg substitute in everything that calls for eggs. Cakes, cookies, etc. usually 1/4 cup of the substitute equals 1 egg, but different brands might vary some. I've not had complaints from hubby on the things I've made with them either. We are trying to cut down on fat, cholesterol, etc., and these work great. Last week for Valentines Day, I made a cake with the egg substitute, and it worked great. Also in place of cooking oil, even though I use only Olive Oil now, I used applesauce. Can't tell the difference, and the cake is very moist. Hope I've helped HUGS AND BLESSINGS Ruthie / squigit2 AT aol.com (02/20/2006)
By Ruthie AKA squigit2 aol.com
Liquid Egg substitutes, I believe, are egg whites. It will tell you on the carton how to measure enough for one egg. The hardest part about using only the egg whites, for me, is that I hate throwing away the yolks. But they are good for the pet dog's coat, and most dogs love them. Or you could make homemade noodles, freeze them and give them to a friend who can eat the yolks. My husband and I have high cholesterol also, but we haven't eliminated eggs, just cut back on the amount we use. Instead of 2 eggs in a recipe, I use 2 egg whites and one egg yolk, or you might try 2 egg whites and 2 Tablespoons of water. This will work for some recipes, but some need the egg for the texture of the finished product. Just figure out which ones by trial and error.
Maybe this will be of assistance to you.....
Now, as to your question about the dry egg whites. I only use them in my buttercream icing so my knowledge is very limited. (I prefer real egg whites but sometimes I need to be cautious because there might be pregnant lady or folks with frail health, eating the cake). I've checked a few places though and the most references I find, for using the dried product is for Meringues, shells, cookies and mushrooms. Just Whites says that they can be used in many baked goods. Here is what they say about their product.
1. Use the table below to determine the amount of Just Whites and water to use:
2. Add Just Whites to warm water. Stir gently for 2 minutes giving the powder time to absorb all the water. Continue to stir until completely dissolved. For best results, use a whisk. To obtain foamy, soft, or hard-peak stage, use an electric or hand-mixer, as you would for fresh egg whites.
3. Just Whites can be added to dry ingredients in any recipe calling for egg whites. Just remember to add water or fruit juice in amounts specified in table above to any liquid (including water) called for in the recipe.
The shelf life of Just Whites is a minimum of five years. A Julian code date is used on the canisters - the middle three numbers will be the day of the year the product was packaged on. The second number in the code indicates the year. '0' being 2000, '1' being 2001, etc.
Store in a dry place. No refrigeration required. Salmonella Negative - Pasteurized for Safety
I hope this helps you a bit.
By toysmom at aol.com
I have been using a product called EEnerGEgg Replacer which can be ordered at www.ener-g.com or purchased at health food stores. It is made of vegetable starches. I use 1 1/4 teaspoon of egg replacer blended with two tablespoons of water to replace one egg. I have only recently begun cooking and baking without eggs. Here is some other advice that I have found helpful from vegetarian websites:
Another good egg substitute for baking is ground flaxseeds. To replace one egg in baking, grind 1 tablespoon of flaxseeds to a powder in a blender. Add three tablespoons of water and blend until the mixture becomes viscous.
If your baked goods have a 'chemical' taste, you might be using too much baking soda or baking powder in combination with the egg replacer in your recipe. Try cutting back slightly on one of these ingredients or add more 'flavor' (such as vanilla extract, etc.) to improve the taste.
For cakes or other sweet recipes, I use either 3 T of unsweetened applesauce or 1/2 of a mashed banana for each egg. (The banana will chance the flavor slightly). This has worked for me every time. If a recipe calls for a lot of eggs, sometimes EnerG isn't enough. I like to combine. For example using 1/4 C of silken tofu for one egg, I'll use half tofu and half EnerG. It works well in cakes that I'm trying to make egg-free. But, then again, it depends! Other times, EnerG is okay byitself.
I also like Flax seeds as an egg sub in some cakes, in sweet bread loaves, cookies, and other baked goods. Use 1 TB of ground flax seeds blended with 3 TB liquid (you can use water, juice, broth, or whatever suits the recipe) for 30 seconds. This is equivalent to 1 egg. Obviously, this won't contribute lightness or height to a cake, but it adds moisture, the best binding, and lots of nutrition. It wouldn't work for something like a veganized angel food cake or a lemon pie filling, for example. It gets an "eggy" consistency just like eggs. If I use it to sub in a non-vegan recipe, I usually add a bit more rising agent, like baking powder or soda. Same for the silken tofu. EnerG adds lightness and lends height. For cakes or other sweet recipes, I use either 3 T of unsweetened applesauce or 1/2 of a mashed banana for each egg. (The banana will chance the flavor slightly). This has worked for me every time.
I have read that soya flour can be used for the egg replacer in banana bread but I have not yet tried that. 1 tbsp. soya flour + 2 tbsp. of water = equivalent of 1 egg
For yeast breads, I use a heaped tablespoon of potato flour (not potato starch) and a blob of soya lecithin plus a little extra liquid for each egg in the recipe. In yeast breads, the egg is acting to make the bread tender and moist, not as a binder like in non-yeast baking. Ener-G works well as a binder for cakes and things.
I found this question and answer related to the egg replacer: Q. I have tried baking vegan cakes and muffins both with and without egg replacer and have found everything to be too dense and wet. Also, I am having a hard time making the egg replacer combine with water'it's always lumpy. I've had similar food at vegan restaurants like 'teany' in New York City, and it tastes like the 'real thing.' Any suggestions?
A. To make egg replacer mix with water, it's best to add the water a little at a time and use a tiny whisk or even your fingers to blend it. Vegan baking involves a lot of trial and error. Offhand, it sounds like you have too much liquid in your recipes if they are too wet and dense. Try cutting back on wet ingredients and try again. If there is a particular restaurant that you frequent whose baked goods you enjoy, why not ask for advice? Perhaps you could talk to the pastry chef when the restaurant isn't busy and get some pointers.
I've used Eggbeaters for baking. I don't like them in an omelet but other uses are just fine. (02/21/2006)
By Jayne Pavone
I also. use Eggbeaters, I have had no problems substituting them for eggs. My husband can't have eggs anymore either, so I just switched to eggbeaters. He can't tell the difference in home baked goods. (02/21/2006)
If you want to use "real" eggs, I would suggest going out in the country and find a nice farmer that raises chickens that are not mistreated. I think the eggs are much tastier than store bought anyway. The chickens are usually free range and not locked up until night so the critters don't get them. Then they are let back out during the day. I raised chickens and they were happy chickens. We never ate any of them. Just the eggs. They died of old age. I see you eat cheese so I'm asumming you eat real eggs.
HERE IN CANADA WE HAVE A PRODUCT FOR BAKING WHICH I'VE USED FOR QUITE A WHILE. i LOVE IT AS IT`S EASY, KEEPS WELL AND NOT EXPENSIVE TO USE. IT'S CALLED Celimix brand egg replacer. IT'S MANUFACTURED BY Nelson David of Canada Ltd.
of Winnipeg,,Manitoba The Phone# ON THE BOX IS: 1-866-989-0379. One tbsp + 4 Tbsps. of water is equal to 1 egg. It is a gluten and wheat free product
. Hope this helps you.
Check out this link - go about half way down the page in the left column:
I've no idea what you would use to substitute eggs, except get a couple of hens and you can control their treatment and then eat their eggs. We have chickens - several of them and their eggs are far superior to the ones you buy at the grocery. If you don't have room, (it doesn't take much, there are tons of ideas for chicken pens and how to keep chickens in a small space, on the internet), you should be able to find someone in the country that sells eggs from their home. They're usually free range and treated very humanely. I have a question though: Do you think the dairy cattle whose milk produces the cheese you eat, are treated more humanely then the chickens used for egg production? I am doubtful.
This is a delicious choc cake recipe. Don't have to be vegetarian to enjoy it.
1 cup white sugar
1 1/2 cups flour
1/2 tsp salt
1/4 cup cocoa
1 tsp soda
1 TBLS vinegar
1 tsp vanilla
1/2 cup salad oil
1 cup cold water
Mix all ingredients together til smooth.
Bake in 8X8 sprayed cake pan at 350 for 30-35mins.
Cup cakes bake 350 degree for 14-15 mins.
I usually double recipe and use 9X13 pan, or two round pans, or get 1 1/2 dozen cupcakes.
Just buy eggs from a local egg grower who treats chickens well! I recently had six hens and they produced too many for myself and two neighbors.
Hi I am vegetarian too. I use flax seed and water as an egg substitute when baking.
1 tablespoon flax seeds
3 tablespoons water
Let stand a few minutes to thicken to a consistency like egg white. Strain seeds and use liquid.
I use the following link to get recipes for vegetarian ideas.
Go to www.recipezaar.com
In the pink area click on "by diet"
then under dietary click vegetarian, there is over 33,000 recipes.
Just click on a category and the recipes for that category will pop up.
Under the page numbers click on the word rating and the recipes will be sorted by the most tried and will give reviews.
There aren't too many dessert ones but a lot of main courses, soups etc.
If you click home and then type in "vegan" then click on rating there are a lot of desserts, cookies, brownies etc.
Good Luck and enjoy.
I just wanted to echo the soy flour plus water tip. I've used it in the past with success!
Hi. Go to
they have recipes there for vegetarians and vegens.
They also have a place to buy and sell used homeschool curriculum, which is why I go to their site.
Hi I simply use a quarter cup of buttermilk for each egg used to the maximum of two eggs. In place of the water and vinegar that is used in the crazy or whacky chocolate cake I use buttermilk. The cake rises better and is lighter in texture. I have also replaced the eggs in a banana loaf and it came out light and delicious with no problems in rising. The buttermilk is however acidic so I use it mostly in recipes that have baking soda rather than baking powder. If a recipe has baking powder and baking soda I increase the baking soda a little and decrease the baking powder.
I put when baking a cake or other things like that apple sauce.... or you put 1/4 cup of oil... for 1 egg...
I bake without eggs all the time as my son is allergic to them. For most recipes you can simply substitute 1 tablespoon water and 1 tablespoon white vinegar combined with 1 teaspoon baking powder for each egg. I've found it to work in cakes, cupcakes, breads, etc.
This is a guide about egg-free cookie cake recipe. This tasty cookie-like cake is the perfect dessert for someone cutting or reducing eggs and oils in their diet.